Smoked Shrimp-Stuffed Peppers

Smoked Shrimp-Stuffed Peppers

Smoked Shrimp-Stuffed Peppers


I grew up on a small horse farm in Northwest New Jersey. I suppose you could say we started practicing the idea of local, sustainable food in our family, over 20 year ago. However, as a child, I didn’t appreciate it, nor did I even remotely like gardening. Now gardening has become one of my favorite activities. Not only does it provide us with fresh and flavorful ingredients, but it’s a light form of exercise on a hot day.

I try to utilize my garden space for vegetables that may not be readily available at the grocery stores or carry a hefty pricetag. It is much more affordable to grow heirloom vegetable varieties in your backyard than purchasing them at the local market. I also find these less popular varieties of vegetables to hold a more unique flavor. This recipe features the lesser-known Cowbell Pepper, as well as a few fresh herbs! If you don’t have cowbell peppers, small traditional green, yellow, or red bell peppers will work nicely.

As for the stuffing, I decided to break out the smoker. If a smoker is not something readily available to you, it is possible to turn your outdoor grill into a smoker as well. Most home improvement stores and even some grocery stores carry Hickory or Applewood chips. Just be sure to soak the chips in water for at least 12 hours. And if using a regular grill, wrap these up in foil, and set over the flame. Soaking the chips is necessary so that they smoke and not burn. The smoking process may increase your cooking time on the shrimp. Mine took approximately 15 minutes. If smoking is not possible, you can still make this recipe with any cooked shrimp.

Smoked Shrimp-Stuffed Peppers
Prep time
Cook time
Total time
Serves: 4-5
Dry Rub
  • 1 tsp Old Bay
  • 1 tsp Cumin
  • 1 tsp Paprika
  • 12 Large Shrimp
  • 4-5 large Cowbell Peppers, tops removed and seeded
  • Pepper Stuffing
  • 4-5 smoked shrimp, finely chopped
  • 3 oz cream cheese, softened
  • 2 TBSP mayonnaise
  • ½ tsp Old Bay
  • 1 TBSP fresh chives, chopped fine
  • 1 tsp fresh parsley, chopped fine
  • ½ cup of shredded cheddar or mozzarella cheese
  1. Mix together dry rub ingredients and rub onto raw shrimp. Let sit for 20-30 minutes, then smoke or grill.
  2. Thoroughly mix together all stuffing ingredients and hand stuff into the peppers. Stuffing mixture can also be placed into a heavy duty plastic bag or pastry bag for stuffing peppers.
  3. These peppers can be baked or grilled. You may be able to find a pepper stand that fits in your oven or on your grill. I find cooking them upright keeps from loosing the filling and helps the filling absorb the flavor of the pepper. Alternatively, you can wrap these in foil for cooking. The grill or oven should be set at about 400. Cook these for approximately 8-10 minutes. Serve the extra smoked shrimp on the side of the peppers. Enjoy!

Blueberry Mint Julep square

Blueberry Mint Julep Spritzer

I love the sound of a mint julep. Sweetened up bourbon and mint? Yum. Plus all that tradition just appeals to the Southern girl in me. According to the Cocktail Times, the mint julep first appeared in print in 1803 as a “dram of spirituous liquor that has mint in it, taken by Virginians in… 

Read More »

Orecchiette square option 2

Handmade Orecchiette with Fava Beans & Ricotta

I’ve always loved orecchiette because of the cuteness factor. A traditional Southern Italian pasta, the word literally means “little ears,” which is exactly what it looks like. Adorable.  There’s also the huge bonus that it’s easy to make. You don’t need a pasta machine or any other speciality tools. Since it’s just a simple mixture… 

Read More »

Cucumber noodles

Spicy Cucumber Noodles with Blueberries

The pitcher  and cups in this photograph –  old Dutch-made blue willow -  were in my great aunt Johnnie Dell Ridgdill’s tiny kitchen for as long as I can remember. Aunt Johnnie was a force in my childhood. A retired nurse, she helped my grandmother Colleen raise my mother after my mother’s father, Charles, died from colon cancer when… 

Read More »

Cherry Muffin thumbnail for recipe

Cherry Chocolate Chunk Walnut Muffins

These are some serious, blow your mind muffins. The test kitchen ate a whole batch on a Sunday afternoon. My neighbor planned to share hers with a houseguest, but took one bite and reconsidered. I sent a batch to work with J, and his coworkers – a witty, sophisticated and discerning bunch – agreed that testing… 

Read More »

Gingered Blueberry Shortcake is a special addition to a brunch menu.

Gingered Blueberry Shortcake

There’s a reason blueberries are a superfood. That deep blue color is from antioxidants that boost the immune system, prevent infections, and protect the brain and the heart from inflammation. They also can help reduce belly fat and fight urinary tract infections. Most importantly, they taste amazing. The best way to reap the healthy benefits of blueberries… 

Read More »

Cucumber & Tomato & Salad with Mint Option 2

Cucumber and Tomato Salad with Mint

Well into the growing season, our community supported agriculture program and our garden have been providing all of the vegetables our families needs, with some left over for preserving, for a few weeks now. I hadn’t realized it until I ran into the grocery store the other day for some red wine vinegar, but it’s… 

Read More »

Grilled Peaches Over Vanilla Ice Cream, option 3

Grilled Peaches over Vanilla Ice Cream

Summertime is famous for outdoor cooking, especially anything grilled. Grilling fruit brings out its natural sugars and makes for a great summertime desert. And when I think dessert, I think ice cream. Now combine the two together and it’s mouth-watering magic. Many fruits are grillable, including apples, pineapple, peaches, pears, watermelon, and mango. Today’s dish… 

Read More »

This week's community supported agriculture bounty.

Nothing Wasted: Making the Most of a CSA or Garden

I’m loving all the beautiful vegetables I’m getting from Lancaster Farm Fresh, my community supported agriculture program. I know I’ve mentioned this before, and if I appear to be gushing, I guess I am. This afternoon’s take included some really beautiful fresh fava beans, bull’s blood beets, four huge heirloom tomatoes and some miniature white… 

Read More »

Rustic grilled pizza with zucchini, garlic, and basil leaves.

Rustic Grilled Pizza with Zucchini, Garlic & Fresh Basil

Spring may have come late this year, but the vegetables in my garden are coming in early. The alternating heat and rain the East Coast has been getting must be doing the trick, because my tomato plants are heavy with fruit and we’re flush with jalapeños and banana peppers too. Since we’re usually overrun by squash and… 

Read More »

Peach Sweet Tea and Rum

Georgia meet Bermuda: Peach Sweet Tea & Rum

Some might say I travel a bit, why yes I do! Last month my roommate and I joined my parents on a fabulous cruise from Baltimore to Bermuda. Once at the island, we rented scooters to tour the island and it’s famous pink sand beaches. Of course, it wouldn’t be a fabulous island vacation without… 

Read More »